My older brother (39M) and I (32M) have never been especially close because we have very little in common. We get along well enough whenever we see each other at family gatherings and holidays, but our conversations have always stayed pretty surface-level—usually talking about pop culture, sports, or his kids.
I came out when I was very young, and to my surprise, my family was always supportive. I grew up in a Christian household, but I never felt judged or rejected by my parents or siblings because of my sexuality. While attending Christian schools wasn't always easy, home always felt like a safe place where I could simply be myself.
That changed this year.
In September, I got engaged to my partner of five years.
I'm not religious, and I haven't been for a long time.
My brother, however, has become increasingly devout over the past twenty years, especially after marrying his wife around 2013. They're the type of Christians who genuinely believe yoga can invite demonic influence and that Satan plays an active role in current political events.
Because of that, I've always avoided discussing religion with them.
When I announced our engagement in the family group chat, I expected a simple congratulations.
Instead...
Only my sister, my mom, and my half-brother congratulated us.
My older brother...
His wife...
And even my dad...
Said absolutely nothing.
At first I thought maybe they were just busy.
My sister thought the same thing.
My brother has four children and a demanding engineering career, so we assumed he'd eventually reach out.
Days turned into weeks.
Nothing.
The engagement was announced on September 22.
I didn't hear a single word from him until October 11.
When he finally texted me, it wasn't to congratulate me.
Instead, he explained that because of his religious beliefs, he couldn't support my marriage or attend my wedding.
Reading those messages was devastating.
It wasn't simply that he was declining an invitation.
It felt like he was rejecting one of the most important moments of my life.
Before responding, I spent several days thinking about whether this was something our relationship could survive. I even spoke with a close friend who works in family mediation, and they reminded me that disagreements over deeply held religious beliefs often become even more complicated when they intersect with major life events like marriage. They encouraged me to separate two different questions: whether my brother had the right to make his own decision, and whether I had the right to decide what kind of relationship I wanted with someone who couldn't support my marriage. That conversation made me realize this wasn't really about one wedding invitation—it was about trust, acceptance, and whether we could continue having an honest relationship going forward.
After I sent my reply...
I blocked his number.
I know that probably sounds extreme.
But in my mind, I couldn't imagine continuing a normal brotherly relationship with someone who couldn't support or respect my right to marry the person I love.
Why should he be able to separate "loving me as a brother" from refusing to acknowledge one of the biggest milestones in my life?
Later, my sister spoke with him.
According to her, he explained that as the "leader of his family," he didn't want to set what he believed would be the wrong example for his children.
That explanation only confused me more.
My fiancé and I have spent plenty of time around his kids over the past five years.
We've attended birthdays.
Family holidays.
Cookouts.
No one ever acted like our relationship was a problem.
The only thing that changed...
Was the fact that we were getting married.
His birthday recently passed.
For the first time in probably twenty-five years...
I didn't call.
I didn't text.
I didn't wish him a happy birthday.
Now I'm sitting here wondering whether I've already made the decision to cut him out of my life permanently.
Part of me feels guilty.
Another part of me feels like maintaining a relationship after this would only mean pretending none of it happened.
So...
Am I overreacting?
Or is it reasonable to step away from someone who can't support one of the most important days of my life?
Social Plugin